Hobby SupermarketHobbySupermarket

The Best Card Binder for Pokémon, MTG and Toploaders

Pockets per page, side-loading pockets, a zip or not, and how many cards each holds

For most collections the best binder is a zip-closing 9-pocket binder with side-loading pockets, holding about 360 cards: the zip keeps cards in if the binder is dropped or carried in a bag, and side-loading pockets keep a card from sliding out of the top. These are the binders the shops we track sell most widely:

Ultimate Guard Zipfolio 360 XenoSkin Magic: The Gathering Reality Fracture - Jace, Reality Sculptor / Tam, the Possibility

Zipfolio 360 zippered binder, 9-pocket pages, holds 360 cards · UGD011982

Ultimate Guard

  • free economy shipping over $99 to the contiguous US; below that, the fee shows at checkout · dispatched in 1 working day · 30-day returns
Ultra Pro 12-Pocket Zippered PRO-Binder Vivid Black

12-pocket zippered card binder, holds 480 cards · UP-15891

Ultra Pro

  • free economy shipping over $99 to the contiguous US; below that, the fee shows at checkout · dispatched in 1 working day · 30-day returns
Ultra Pro 9-Pocket Zippered PRO-Binder Vivid Black

9-pocket zippered card binder, holds 360 cards · UP-15907

Ultra Pro

  • free economy shipping over $99 to the contiguous US; below that, the fee shows at checkout · dispatched in 1 working day · 30-day returns
  • ships across the US from Owasso, Oklahoma, within 3 business days (most the next day); 3 to 9 business days by USPS or UPS · 30-day returns

Every binder we compare is on the card binders shelf.

How we chose

We read each maker's own figures (pockets per page, capacity, closure) and the prices of the shops we track in your market. We have not handled these binders ourselves. The picks favour binders several shops sell, so you can compare prices.

What to look for

ChoiceWhat it meansWho it suits
9-pocket (often sold as "18-pocket", counting both sides)3 x 3 cards per pageMost collectors; a set or a deck reads in rows of three
12-pocket (24-pocket counting both sides)3 x 4 cards per pageBig collections; more cards per binder
4-pocket or 8-pocket2 x 2 cards per pageA small binder for trades or a few favourites
Side-loading pocketsThe card goes in from the sideCards stay in when the binder is tipped up
Zip closureThe binder zips shutCarrying the binder in a bag
Sized for toploadersLarger pockets that take a card in a toploaderCards you already keep in toploaders

Makers quote capacity in cards, and some count both sides of a page as one "18-pocket" page. A Zipfolio 360, for example, holds 360 cards. Check whether the figure means single-sleeved or double-sleeved cards: Ultimate Guard sizes its Zipfolio 360 pockets for double-sleeved cards, with side-loading pockets and a zip (Ultimate Guard: Zipfolio 360). For the sleeves themselves, see our card sleeve sizes guide.

Zip-closing 9-pocket binders (360 cards)

The everyday pick. Ultimate Guard's Zipfolio 360 and Ultra Pro's 9-pocket Zippered PRO-Binder both hold 360 cards behind a zip.

Ultimate Guard Zipfolio 360 XenoSkin Magic: The Gathering Reality Fracture - Ajani Resolute / Ajani Unrelenting

Zipfolio 360 zippered binder, 9-pocket pages, holds 360 cards · UGD011983

Ultimate Guard

  • free economy shipping over $99 to the contiguous US; below that, the fee shows at checkout · dispatched in 1 working day · 30-day returns
Ultimate Guard Zipfolio 360 XenoSkin Magic: The Gathering Reality Fracture - Chandra, Chill of Compliance / Chandra, Torch of Defiance

Zipfolio 360 zippered binder, 9-pocket pages, holds 360 cards · UGD011984

Ultimate Guard

  • free economy shipping over $99 to the contiguous US; below that, the fee shows at checkout · dispatched in 1 working day · 30-day returns
Ultra Pro 9-Pocket Zippered PRO-Binder Vivid Blue

9-pocket zippered card binder, holds 360 cards · UP-15900

Ultra Pro

  • ships across the US from Owasso, Oklahoma, within 3 business days (most the next day); 3 to 9 business days by USPS or UPS · 30-day returns

Pokémon card binders

Pokémon cards are standard size, so any 9-pocket binder fits them. Ultra Pro makes the binders with Pokémon art under licence, from small 4-pocket binders to 12-pocket PRO-Binders.

Ultra Pro Pokémon Premium Snap Binder Blue (4-Pocket)

4-pocket snap binder, holds 160 cards · UP-16375

Ultra Pro

  • ships across the US from Miami, Florida, sent within a business day · no returns

Big binders (480 cards and up)

For a large collection, a 12-pocket page holds a third more cards than a 9-pocket page, and some portfolios hold more than 480 cards.

Ultra Pro 12-Pocket Zippered PRO-Binder Vivid Black

12-pocket zippered card binder, holds 480 cards · UP-15891

Ultra Pro

  • free economy shipping over $99 to the contiguous US; below that, the fee shows at checkout · dispatched in 1 working day · 30-day returns
Ultimate Guard Zipfolio 480 XenoSkin Magic: The Gathering Reality Fracture - Way of the Wildspeaker / Way of the Deathbringer

Zipfolio 480 zippered binder, 12-pocket pages, holds 480 cards · UGD011979

Ultimate Guard

  • free economy shipping over $99 to the contiguous US; below that, the fee shows at checkout · dispatched in 1 working day · 30-day returns
Ultimate Guard Zipfolio 480 XenoSkin Magic: The Gathering Reality Fracture - Liliana the Faultless / Liliana the Repentant

Zipfolio 480 zippered binder, 12-pocket pages, holds 480 cards · UGD011980

Ultimate Guard

  • free economy shipping over $99 to the contiguous US; below that, the fee shows at checkout · dispatched in 1 working day · 30-day returns

Open portfolios, without a zip

A portfolio without a zip is lighter and cheaper, and suits a binder that stays on a shelf. Ultimate Guard's FlexXfolio and Dragon Shield's Card Codex are the lines the shops we track stock most.

Binders for toploaders

A toploader is a rigid holder for one card. Ordinary binder pockets are too small for one, so a toploader binder has larger pockets. BCW's Z-Folio LX is a zip-closing 9-pocket album sized for toploaders.

BCW Z-Folio 9-Pocket LX Album for Toploaders Black

Zippered 9-pocket LX album sized for toploaders

BCW

  • ships across the US by USPS, UPS or FedEx (rate at checkout); standard 3-7 business days after 1-3 days processing · no returns
Ultra Pro 3" x 4" Regular Toploaders (25)

Clear rigid 3" x 4" toploaders for standard-size cards (regular, 35pt), 25 per pack · UP-81222 · 25

Ultra Pro

  • ships across the US from Lexington, Kentucky; the fee is shown at checkout · 7-day returns
Ultra Pro Penny Sleeves Standard Size (100)

Soft standard-size (2.5" x 3.5") penny sleeves, 100 per pack · UP-81126

Ultra Pro

  • $6.99 US delivery, 3–5 working days · 30-day returns
  • $10 US delivery, 4–8 working days, free over $75 · 14-day returns

A card goes into a penny sleeve first, then the toploader. More on the toploaders shelf, and our card storage guide covers which cards go in a binder, a box or a toploader.

Ring binders and loose pages

A binder with rings takes loose 9-pocket pages, so it can grow with a collection; a binder with bound-in pages, like the ones above, holds a fixed number of cards. For a ring binder, Ultimate Guard sells side-loading 18-pocket pages in packs of 10.

Questions

What is the best Pokémon card binder?

A zip-closing 9-pocket binder with side-loading pockets suits most Pokémon collections. Ultra Pro makes the licensed Pokémon binders; any standard-size 9-pocket binder fits Pokémon cards.

How many cards does a 9-pocket binder hold?

It depends on the page count. The 9-pocket binders in this guide hold 360 cards; check the figure on the binder's own page.

Do sleeved cards fit in a binder?

Most binders take single-sleeved cards. Ultimate Guard sizes its Zipfolio 360 pockets for double-sleeved cards. Check the maker's figure before you sleeve a whole collection.

Can I put toploaders in a binder?

Only in a binder made for them, such as BCW's Z-Folio LX. Ordinary pockets are too small for a toploader.

Each binder's own page, opened from the cards above, lists the shops we track in your market, cheapest first.

Price the hobby

Everything named on this site carries its price across the shops we track.

Hobby Supermarket

Prices on miniatures, paints, brushes, 3D printing and trading cards, compared across the shops we track in the UK, US, Europe, Canada and Australia.

Deals by email

Send me deals for
Tell us what you play (optional)
What are you into? (optional)
Which games?
Which card games?

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We also earn commission as a Wayland Games affiliate and through the eBay Partner Network, Awin and other retailer programmes. See how we make money.

Warhammer, Warhammer 40,000, Age of Sigmar, Citadel and Games Workshop are trademarks of Games Workshop Ltd. Magic: The Gathering is a trademark of Wizards of the Coast, Pokémon of Nintendo, Creatures and GAME FREAK, and Yu-Gi-Oh! of Konami. Other product and brand names belong to their owners. Hobby Supermarket is an independent, unofficial site, not affiliated with, endorsed or sponsored by any of them.

Featured on tools.cafe