The safest gift for a Magic: The Gathering player is one they use every game: card sleeves and a deck box. A pack of 100 sleeves fits a Commander deck, and most players own more decks than good boxes to keep them in. For sealed product, a Commander deck suits someone who plays with friends, a bundle suits someone who likes opening packs, and a Beginner Box is made to teach a new player. Four safe picks:
The shops we compare do not sell Magic products or card accessories in Australia yet, so this edition has no product cards. We are looking for Australian shops to add. Until then, the hobby gift ideas hub has gifts for painters, Warhammer players and 3D printing fans that Australian shops do sell.
Every card on this page is priced at the shops we compare in your market, and anything none of them sells where you are is left out. Black Friday is on 27 November; the Black Friday page shows which shops are running a sale. For other hobbies, see the hobby gift ideas hub.
MTG gift ideas at a glance
| Budget | For a Commander player | For a drafter or pack opener | For a new player |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stocking stuffer | 100 sleeves, a deck box | A few Play Booster packs | A Play Booster pack |
| Mid-range | A Commander deck, a binder | A bundle | A Beginner Box |
| Big-ticket | A Collector's Edition Commander deck, a playmat | A Play Booster box | A Beginner Box plus a Commander deck |
Questions to ask first
- Which format do they play? Commander (100-card decks, usually four players around a table) is the most popular casual format. Drafters and pack openers want boosters. A player who only plays at home with friends usually plays Commander.
- Which sleeve size? Magic cards take standard-size sleeves, the same as Pokémon. The card size and sleeve finder confirms it.
- Do they collect a set or a franchise? Recent Magic sets include Universes Beyond crossovers such as Final Fantasy, Marvel, The Hobbit and Star Trek. A fan of the franchise may want that set even if they rarely play.
MTG stocking stuffers (stocking fillers)
Sleeves
Sleeves protect cards from wear and are used up over time, so a fresh pack is always useful. Packs of 100 fit a Commander deck. Matte sleeves shuffle more easily and reflect less light than glossy ones; best card sleeves compares the brands, and card sleeve sizes explains the sizes.
A deck box
A deck box sold as 100+ holds a sleeved Commander deck; a 133+ box has room for tokens and a few spares. The Commander deck box guide compares the designs.
Booster packs
A single pack is the classic stocking filler. Play Boosters are the standard pack for playing and opening; Collector Boosters hold more foils and special cards and cost much more. Play vs Collector Boosters explains the difference.
Mid-range MTG gifts
A Commander deck
A Commander deck is a ready-to-play 100-card deck, the gift for someone who plays at a kitchen table with friends. Decks are built around a theme and a commander, and a player can use one straight out of the box. Best Commander precon decks sorts the current decks by colour and theme, and how to build a Commander deck explains the format.
For someone who has never played Commander, a Foundations Commander deck is made to introduce the format; in the US, Starter Commander Decks do the same job.
A bundle
A bundle holds Play Boosters, basic lands and a storage box, a good gift for someone who likes opening packs and building decks from them.
A binder
For a collector, a binder keeps their best cards safe and on show. A zippered binder protects cards from falling out in a bag; best card binder compares them.
Big-ticket MTG gifts
A Play Booster box
A Play Booster box is a full display of packs, enough for a group to draft or for one player to open a big part of a set. It is the big gift for a keen drafter or collector. A Draft Night box holds 12 Play Boosters, a Collector Booster and basic lands: a night of drafting for a small group.
Gift bundles and Collector's Editions
A gift bundle is a bundle with extra contents, made for giving. A Collector's Edition Commander deck has the same decklist as the standard deck, with every card foil and many in alternate art, which suits a player who already enjoys the deck's franchise.
A playmat
A playmat protects cards on the table and is a nice thing to own that many players never buy for themselves. MTG playmat size gives the standard dimensions.
Gifts for someone new to Magic
A Beginner Box is designed to teach the game, with ready-to-play decks and a guided first game. Beginner Box vs Starter Kit compares the two ways in. Add sleeves and a deck box and they have everything they need.
Tips for buying a gift for a Magic player
- Sleeves and a deck box are always safe. Players get through sleeves, and a good deck box is rarely a duplicate.
- Ask which format they play. A Commander deck suits a Commander player; a booster box suits a drafter or collector.
- Do not buy single cards unless they have asked for a specific card. Players build decks carefully, and a random rare is rarely the one they need.
- Check the language. Some shops sell non-English editions of the same product. The cards on this page are English editions.
- Compare the shops. Sealed product prices move with demand and vary between shops, especially around Black Friday. Every card above shows the prices we track in your market.
What is a good gift for an MTG player?
Sleeves and a deck box are always used, and a pack of 100 sleeves fits a Commander deck. For sealed product, a Commander deck suits a casual player, a bundle suits someone who likes opening packs, and a Play Booster box suits a keen drafter or collector.
What are good MTG stocking stuffers?
A pack of 100 sleeves, a deck box or a few Play Booster packs. All three are small and used by almost every player.
Is a Commander deck a good gift?
Yes, for anyone who plays Commander with friends. A Commander deck is a ready-to-play 100-card deck that works straight out of the box. If they have never played, a Beginner Box or a Foundations Commander deck is an easier start.
What should I buy someone who wants to start playing Magic?
A Beginner Box, which is designed to teach the game with ready-to-play decks, plus sleeves and a deck box. If they will play with a Commander group, add a Commander deck.
What size sleeves do Magic cards take?
Standard-size sleeves, the same size as Pokémon cards. Japanese-size sleeves, made for Yu-Gi-Oh!, are too small for Magic cards.
