Hobby SupermarketHobbySupermarket

How to Store Pokémon and MTG Cards: Binders, Boxes and Toploaders

A binder, a box, a toploader or a deck box, and which cards belong in each

Store each card by what it is for. Cards you want to look at go in a binder with side-loading pockets. Bulk you rarely touch goes upright in a storage box. A valuable card goes in a penny sleeve, then a toploader. A deck you play goes in sleeves and a deck box. Pokémon and Magic cards are the same standard size, so the same binders, sleeves and boxes fit both. Most collections start with a zipped, side-loading binder. These are the binders the shops we track sell most widely:

None of the shops we track in Australia sells card binders, storage boxes, sleeves or toploaders yet, so this edition shows no storage products or prices.

Every binder we compare is on the card binders shelf. Not sure which size your game's cards are? Our card size and sleeve finder gives each game's card size and the sleeves and toploaders that fit, with pages for Pokémon and Magic.

Which storage for which cards

CardsStore them inWhy
Your collection, the cards you want to seeA 9-pocket or 12-pocket binderEvery card on show, one per pocket
Bulk: commons, duplicates, cards you rarely useA storage box, cards uprightHolds hundreds or thousands of cards in little space
Single valuable cardsA penny sleeve, then a toploaderA rigid holder that keeps the card flat
Decks you playSleeves and a deck boxProtects the cards you shuffle every game
Sealed packs and boxesKept sealed, out of the sunNothing to do except keep them dry

Whatever you use, the usual advice from collectors is the same: keep cards somewhere dry, cool and out of direct sunlight, keep them flat or upright rather than stacked under weight, and do not hold stacks together with rubber bands, which dent the edges.

Binders: for the cards you want to look at

A binder shows every card at once, so it suits a set you are completing, your favourite cards, or a trade binder. Look for:

  • Side-loading pockets: the card goes in from the side, so it stays in when the binder is tipped up.
  • A zip, if the binder travels in a bag.
  • 9 or 12 pockets a page. Makers often count both sides of a page, so an "18-pocket" page holds 9 cards a side.

Bound-in pages, like the binders above, hold a fixed number of cards. A ring binder takes loose pages, so it can grow with a collection. Our card binder guide compares binders by size and capacity.

Storage boxes: for bulk

Most of a collection is cards you will not look at often. They go upright in a box, sorted however you like (by set, by colour or type), with dividers between sections. Ultimate Guard names its boxes by capacity in cards, for example the Arkhive 400+ and the Omnihive 1000+; check the maker's page for whether that figure means sleeved or unsleeved cards.

More on the card storage and deck boxes shelves.

Penny sleeves and toploaders: for valuable cards

A penny sleeve is a thin, soft, clear sleeve for storing a card, not for shuffling. A toploader is a rigid plastic holder for one card. Put the card in a penny sleeve first, then slide it into the toploader: the sleeve keeps the card from scuffing on the way in. Ultra Pro's regular toploader is 3" x 4", sized for a standard card. A toploader goes in a box or a binder made for toploaders; ordinary binder pockets are too small.

Few shops we track sell toploaders yet, so some editions show only one or two here. More on the toploaders shelf.

Sleeves and a deck box: for decks you play

Playing sleeves are thicker than penny sleeves and made to be shuffled. A pack of 100 standard sleeves covers a 60-card Pokémon or Magic deck with spares, or one 100-card Commander deck. The deck then goes in a deck box sized for it: a "100+" box holds a sleeved Commander deck.

Our card sleeves guide covers which sleeves to buy and our Commander deck box guide which boxes hold a sleeved deck.

Pokémon cards vs MTG cards

Both are standard size, so one set of storage works for both. The differences are in what people keep: Pokémon collectors often fill a binder set by set, so a 9-pocket binder, which lays a page out three by three, is a common choice, and Ultra Pro makes licensed Pokémon binders. Magic players more often keep decks in deck boxes and the rest of a collection in bulk boxes. Yu-Gi-Oh! cards are smaller (Japanese size), so check the binder or sleeve size before you buy; our card sleeve sizes guide lists every game.

Questions

What is the best way to store Pokémon cards?

Cards you want to look at in a side-loading 9-pocket binder; bulk upright in a storage box; valuable cards in a penny sleeve and then a toploader. Keep all of them dry and out of direct sunlight.

How do you store MTG cards?

Decks you play in sleeves and a deck box, the rest of a collection upright in a storage box with dividers, and the cards you want on show in a binder.

Should I put cards in a penny sleeve before a toploader?

Yes. The penny sleeve stops the card scuffing as it slides into the toploader.

Do Pokémon and MTG cards fit the same binders and sleeves?

Yes. Both are standard size. Yu-Gi-Oh! cards are smaller and take Japanese-size sleeves.

We compare products by the makers' own figures and the prices of the shops we track in your market; we have not handled them ourselves. Checked against our catalogue on 15 November 2026.

Price the hobby

Everything named on this site carries its price across the shops we track.

Hobby Supermarket

Prices on miniatures, paints, brushes, 3D printing and trading cards, compared across the shops we track in the UK, US, Europe, Canada and Australia.

Deals by email

Send me deals for
Tell us what you play (optional)
What are you into? (optional)
Which games?
Which card games?

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We also earn commission as a Wayland Games affiliate and through the eBay Partner Network, Awin and other retailer programmes. See how we make money.

Warhammer, Warhammer 40,000, Age of Sigmar, Citadel and Games Workshop are trademarks of Games Workshop Ltd. Magic: The Gathering is a trademark of Wizards of the Coast, Pokémon of Nintendo, Creatures and GAME FREAK, and Yu-Gi-Oh! of Konami. Other product and brand names belong to their owners. Hobby Supermarket is an independent, unofficial site, not affiliated with, endorsed or sponsored by any of them.

Featured on tools.cafe