Hobby SupermarketHobbySupermarket

ASA vs ABS for Terrain and Miniatures: UV and Heat

Two enclosure filaments, and why ASA is the one for sun and heat

If you have an enclosed printer and the piece will sit in sunlight or heat, print it in ASA. Prusa calls ASA a successor to ABS that is "more UV resistant, warps less, and doesn't smell as much", and eSUN's figures put its heat resistance well above ABS. ABS still makes sense for tough parts kept indoors and for acetone smoothing. Both need an enclosure. These are 1 kg spools of each, in black, white and grey, from brands several of the shops we track sell:

ELEGOO ASA Filament 1kg, Deep Black

UV- and weather-resistant ASA filament for outdoor parts · 1kg

ELEGOO

  • free US delivery over $50 (48 contiguous states + DC only), $15 flat rate below that, 3-7 business days · 14-day returns
QIDI Tech ASA Filament 1kg, White

ASA filament: UV- and weather-resistant, prints like ABS · 1kg

QIDI Tech

  • dispatched in 1–2 working days
eSUN ASA+ Filament 1kg, Grey

ASA filament: UV- and weather-resistant, for outdoor parts; needs a heated bed and ideally an enclosure · 1kg, 1.75 mm

eSUN

  • free US delivery over $99, 7–14 working days · 14-day returns
ELEGOO ABS Filament 1kg, Grey

ABS filament: tougher and more heat-resistant than PLA, needs a heated bed and ideally an enclosure · 1kg

ELEGOO

  • free US delivery over $50 (48 contiguous states + DC only), $15 flat rate below that, 3-7 business days · 14-day returns
Creality Hyper ABS Filament 1kg, Black

ABS-family filament: tougher and more heat-resistant than PLA, needs a heated bed and ideally an enclosure · 1kg, 1.75 mm

Creality

SUNLU ABS Filament 1kg, Grey

ABS filament: tougher and more heat-resistant than PLA, needs a heated bed and ideally an enclosure · 1kg

SUNLU

  • free US shipping from their US warehouses (mainland only), 1-3 days processing then 5-10 business days · 14-day returns

Both are on the ABS and ASA shelf, priced per kilo in your currency. Settings for sixteen filaments are side by side in our filament temperature chart.

ASA vs ABS at a glance

ASAABS
Nozzle temperature (eSUN)250-280 °C255-275 °C
Bed temperature (eSUN)90-110 °C95-110 °C
Part cooling fan (eSUN)0-30%Off
EnclosureYes: eSUN and Prusa both call for oneYes: eSUN and Prusa both call for one
Heat distortion (eSUN)96 °C78 °C
Impact strength, Izod (eSUN)20.1 kJ/m²26.5 kJ/m²
UV and outdoorsPrusa: "suitable for outdoor use, due to its high UV light and temperature resistance"Not described as UV resistant by either maker
Warping and smellPrusa: warps less than ABS and smells lessPrusa: warping and toxic fumes are the main disadvantages
SmoothingNot described by either makerSmooths with acetone vapour (Prusa)
Drying80 °C for 4 hours (Prusa)Not stated by either maker
Best forTerrain, signs and storage that sit in sun or heatTough indoor parts, acetone-smoothed finishes

The ASA figures are from eSUN's ASA+ page and the ABS figures from its ABS page. The Prusa lines are from its ASA and ABS articles and its drying table. Prusa gives ASA "temperature resistance (up to 93 °C)". Start from your spool's label.

Why ASA for sun and heat

ASA's advantage is the weather. Prusa says it is "suitable for outdoor use, due to its high UV light and temperature resistance", and eSUN measures its ASA+ heat distortion at 96 °C against 78 °C for its ABS. That suits garden gaming tables and outdoor terrain, a display on a sunny windowsill, signs and labels for a shop or club, and storage that lives in a hot car or a summer loft.

It is also kinder to print. Prusa says ASA warps less than ABS and does not smell as much, though it still "releases potentially dangerous fumes during printing", so it wants the same ventilated room.

ELEGOO ASA Filament 1kg, Grey

UV- and weather-resistant ASA filament for outdoor parts · 1kg

ELEGOO

  • free US delivery over $50 (48 contiguous states + DC only), $15 flat rate below that, 3-7 business days · 14-day returns
QIDI Tech ASA Filament 1kg, Gray

ASA filament: UV- and weather-resistant, prints like ABS · 1kg

QIDI Tech

  • dispatched in 1–2 working days
eSUN ASA+ Filament 1kg, Red

ASA filament: UV- and weather-resistant, for outdoor parts; needs a heated bed and ideally an enclosure · 1kg, 1.75 mm

eSUN

  • free US delivery over $99, 7–14 working days · 14-day returns

Where ABS still wins

On eSUN's own figures, ABS has the higher Izod impact strength of the two: 26.5 kJ/m² against 20.1. And Prusa notes ABS "can be sanded wet and dry and smoothed with acetone fumes", which melts layer lines into a gloss that suits a smooth vehicle hull. For a tough part that lives indoors, or a finish you plan to vapour-smooth, ABS is the one.

Both need an enclosure

eSUN's printing recommendation for both is enclosed-chamber printing, and Prusa says each should be printed inside an enclosure, in a well-ventilated room but without a draft across the print. On an open printer neither is a good choice. If yours is open and you need something tougher and more heat-tolerant than PLA, print PETG: see PETG vs ABS.

Or add an enclosure: on an open printer it is usually a fold-up tent that sits over the whole machine, and our 3D printer enclosure guide covers the choices. Measure the printer, including the spool holder and the bed's full travel, before choosing a size; the Elegoo one is made for its Neptune printers.

VEVOR 3D Printer Enclosure S0001 (Oxford Cloth, 550 x 650 x 750 mm)

Fabric tent enclosure that goes over a 3D printer to hold temperature and keep dust off; LED light · S0001 · 600D Oxford cloth, inner composite aluminium film · 550 x 650 x 750 mm (L x W x H) · 3DDYJZRTWQWTKNHKO001V9 · 197988907336

VEVOR

ELEGOO 3D Printer Enclosure for Neptune 2/3/4 Series

Fold-up enclosure tent that keeps heat in and draughts out for ABS/ASA printing on a Neptune · Fits Neptune 2/2D/2S/3/3 Pro/4/4 Pro

ELEGOO

  • free US delivery over $50 (48 contiguous states + DC only), $15 flat rate below that, 3-7 business days · 14-day returns

Painting ASA and ABS

Both take acrylic paint over a primer made for plastics. If a painted piece is going outdoors, the paint and varnish need to cope with sunlight too: the ASA underneath will not fade, but the paint on it can. To see what a print costs in either material, our 3D print cost calculator prices it from the spools sold in your region.

Other filament comparisons

Questions

Is ASA better than ABS?

For anything in sunlight or heat, yes. Prusa says ASA is more UV resistant, warps less and smells less than ABS, and eSUN's ASA+ has a heat distortion temperature of 96 °C against 78 °C for its ABS. ABS has the higher impact strength on eSUN's figures and can be acetone-smoothed.

Does ASA need an enclosure?

Yes. eSUN recommends enclosed-chamber printing for ASA, and Prusa says the printer should be inside an enclosure, the same as for ABS.

What temperature do I print ASA at?

eSUN publishes 250-280 °C at the nozzle and a 90-110 °C bed, with the part fan at 0-30%. Prusa runs its own ASA at 260 °C on a 105-110 °C bed.

Is ASA good for outdoor wargaming terrain?

It is the filament its makers recommend for outdoor use, for its UV and heat resistance. Protect the paint on top with a varnish suited to sunlight.

We compare the makers' published settings and the prices at the shops we track; we have not printed with these spools ourselves.

Price the hobby

Everything named on this site carries its price across the shops we track.

Hobby Supermarket

Prices on miniatures, paints, brushes, 3D printing and trading cards, compared across the shops we track in the UK, US, Europe, Canada and Australia.

Deals by email

Send me deals for
Tell us what you play (optional)
What are you into? (optional)
Which games?
Which card games?

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We also earn commission as a Wayland Games affiliate and through the eBay Partner Network, Awin and other retailer programmes. See how we make money.

Warhammer, Warhammer 40,000, Age of Sigmar, Citadel and Games Workshop are trademarks of Games Workshop Ltd. Magic: The Gathering is a trademark of Wizards of the Coast, Pokémon of Nintendo, Creatures and GAME FREAK, and Yu-Gi-Oh! of Konami. Other product and brand names belong to their owners. Hobby Supermarket is an independent, unofficial site, not affiliated with, endorsed or sponsored by any of them.

Featured on tools.cafe